Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Not about Krita, but the steaming pile of fail that is GIMP.

No adjustment layers, and with that no non-destructive editing. No actions that somebody who doesn't know a scripting language can write. (Guess what! I CAN write Python but sometimes I just want to say "oh hey I need to do this 200 more times, I'll just hit record, click the buttons I want, stop recording, and make that action Cmd-F2"). Annoying save dialog. No "Just copy the damn Photoshop keyboard shortcuts" option out of the box. Deafness on the part of the GIMP community that their product is still horrible. The development effort that could have gone in to making a decent photo editor went in to people trying to salvage the disaster that is Gimp. Mediocre Mac support.

I love open source, and use Ubuntu primarily (the Mac references above are due to using a Mac, and therefore Gimp on a Mac from time to time, at work). The user experience is actually BETTER running Photoshop on Windows 7 inside Virtualbox than it is running Gimp. That's just pathetic.



The script record bug[1] was entered into bugzilla on 2001-03-09. Reading the discussion is painful. This is targeted for 3.6, which one of the devs admits is most likely 4-8 years away.

[1]: https://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=51937


yes. thank you for explaining so well how tiring gimp is. I feel like they actively reject any good ui idea if its photoshop like.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: